Skip to main content

Good Guy/Bad Guy: What's the Difference?

"You learn eventually that, while there are no villains, there are no heroes either. And until you make the final discovery that there are only human beings, who are therefore all the more fascinating, you are liable to miss something."   - Paul Gallico

When I was little, I used to watch the villains like Cruella de Vil from 101 Dalmatians or Ursula from The Little Mermaid. I would cringe as they bested the hero and then cheer when they were finally defeated and killed at the end. I was under the impression, as all children are, that villains are bad and the heroes are good. There was never any question; it was black and white. Right was right and wrong was wrong.

If you were to ask any writer what the fundamentals of storytelling are, they would most likely say that you have to have two things. You need someone who wants something and you need someone else standing in the way of that person's goals. Basically, you need a villain.

That's a simple enough concept. Without Ursula, The Little Mermaid would be nothing more than the everyday life of a mermaid. 101 Dalmatians without Cruella de Vil would be a family with a bunch of puppies. Pretty boring, right?

So yeah, stories need conflict. They need an antagonist. These are the basic principles of plot. However, something I find even more fascinating to ponder is this: who exactly said that Ursula was the bad guy? Who ever said that the tiger in The Jungle Book was evil?

By definition, an antagonist is a person that opposes the protagonist, the hero. This could mean that our protagonist, Jane, wants her father to drive her to the mall to get some shoes. Her father, however, refuses to take her. In this story, her father opposes Jane and her goal of going to the mall. Therefore he's the villain. But what if her father has a horrible migraine? What if he was recently in a tragic car accident and now fears driving?

If I were still under the same opinion as my five year old self, I would view the father as "evil."
He is, after all, the villain. But what makes the story interesting is that we have an understanding of the father's motives. We see where he's coming from.

Great writing, in my opinion, captures both sides of the story. We may not like the villian, we may not like like his or her actions, but we know the villain well enough to understand why he does what he does.

After all, a villain does not see himself as a villain. In the mind of Darth Vader, he has his own goals and objectives. If we were to tell the story in his point of view, Luke Skywalker would be his obstacle and, therefore, the villain.

As a writer, it's important to not be too quick to choose sides. You may be in love with your protagonist, but if you dismiss the view point of your antagonist, you lose the opportunity to fully explore the characters you are creating and your story misses out on the depth that it aspires to.

When you really start to think about it, we're all our own heroes, but we've also most likely played the villain in another person's story. And when you begin to slip into the shoes of your characters, or really anyone in life, you will be amazed at what you learn and the fascinating avenues you begin to uncover.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

#AuthorToolBoxBlogHop - 20 Writing Exercises to Get Unstuck

From time to time, it's inevitable that in between those days of ever-flowing creative genius, writers are bound to hit roadblocks. Whether big or small, tiny bits of dialogue, or entire scenes and chapters, sometimes it can feel like an impossible task to carry on. We're just stuck. And while we will eventually work through it, I've discovered through my bouts of feeling stagnant, that there are often ways to accelerate our creative process. For this month's Author Toolbox Blog Hop topic, I'm compiling a list of 20 creative writing exercises to get unstuck. 1. Try another scene and come back later. A number of things could be affecting your ability to write a certain scene, including your emotional state, health, sleep, etc. Sometimes the answer is to simply take a break and return when you're in the right frame of mind. 2. Take out a sheet of paper and write by hand. Writing by hand is known to engage the entire brain, which is why journaling is so of...

October 2020 #AuthorToolboxBlogHop: My (Condensed) Preptober Essentials for NaNoWriMo

 Hallelujah! Fall is finally,  finally here and after months of miserable summer heat, my writer heart is singing praises for this beautiful October weather. I don't know about you, but my creativity always goes into hibernation in the summer and reawakens in the fall. Perhaps it's my minds way of preparing for what I like to think of as the writer's version of a marathon. Yes, that's right. I'm talking about  NaNoWriMo . If you've never heard of National Novel Writing Month, I'll give you the gist. Every November, participants undertake a complete rough draft of a brand new novel. In order to "win," your manuscript must reach 50,000 words. And while the prize consists mostly of bragging rights and a general feeling of achievement, Scrivener does offer a 50% discount to verified winners.  While this year will be only my second to participate, I resolved after last years win to commit every year going forward. For me, NaNoWriMo is a perfect excuse t...

#Authortoolboxbloghop Create More Time to Write in 2020: 20+ Ideas to Reclaim Your Schedule

The new year is officially here and like many, I have committed myself to several new goals I want to accomplish in my life and writing career. And while I think goal-setting is admirable, setting achievable goals with a specific, direct path to success is even better. The link between time-management and writing might not be an obvious one, however I find that so often it is the obstacles in my daily personal life that prevent me from advancing in my writing. There have been many lessons I've learned in the past few years that have helped me take control over my schedule and carve out time not only for writing, but related activities that have propelled my writing to the next level. I've compiled a list of time-saving ideas that can reduce time spent on the mundane activities of everyday life. Hopefully some of these will inspire some changes to help you master your schedule this year and spend more time on what you love. Photo by Samantha Gades on Unsplash Simp...